
A Liminal Catholicism
-
I'm a Christian, but probably not the kind you're thinking of.
Too often, Christianity is associated with judgmentalism, magical thinking, moralism, and stale traditions. My spirituality isn't about any of that.
It's not heaven-focused or sin-obsessed. I don't believe in simplistic, Santa-like versions of God, or the idea that anyone had to die for me to be whole.
My Christianity is about humility, not superiority. It's a call to love and serve, not judge. It's about compassion, kindness, and human dignity—a path of meaning, not magic.
I follow a Jesus who cared about people flourishing, especially the lowly and the marginalized, and creating a world based on love.
My style of Christianity prioritizes simplicity. Big-box churches, baroque cathedrals, rosaries, praise bands, cloying Marian devotion, charismatic gifts, and Latin Masses don't resonate.
I also find the influence of Evangelical theology on Christian thought deeply troubling. The biblical idolatry, legalism, and fundamentalism it has unleashed are repugnant. Instead, I strive for spiritual realism. My focus is on love of neighbor, Mass, and simplicity.
Moreover, I’m a liminal Catholic.
The word liminal originates from the Latin word limen, meaning threshold. It refers to doorways and entrances, boundaries and blurred lines, and spaces in between.
The Irish concept of a thin place is similar. Thin places are entries and exits, blended spaces with spiritual meaning where one reality starts and another ends.
Like a shoreline between sand and sea, a liminal Catholic spiritual path is a space between traditional and nontraditional practices and thinking. It is a space between doctrines, interpretations, and traditional customs and stances.
This means I find meaning on Catholic shores but with one foot in the sand of tradition and one foot in the waters of a Catholicism yet to be.
The following essays provide further insight into my understanding of Liminal Catholicism. I don’t pretend to speak for the Church, only for myself.
A Liminal Catholicism
-
A Liminal Catholicism
A statement of spiritual affiliation and thinking.
-
Mercy Isn't Relativism
An essay on the relationship of love and truth.
-
Meaningful Catholic Participation
Meaningful belonging within the Church
-
The Eucharist
On the sacrament of the open table.
-
Vatican II
A brief introduction to the most recent Ecumenical Council of the Church.
-
Catholic Social Thought
On the role of the church in the world.
-
Personalism
A Catholic understanding of human dignity.
-
Nouvelle Theologie
A brief introduction to a pivotal movement in modern Catholic theology.
-
The Road to Emmaus
Connecting Easter and the Eucharist.
-
Phenomenological Realism
A very brief introduction to an important philosophical movement.
Liminal Catholicism: An Essential Reading List
-
1. The Bible (New American Bible, St. Joseph Edition)
2. The Didache & Thomas O’Loughlin’s Book on The Didache
3. The Documents of Vatican II
4. The Encyclicals of John Paul II
5. The Documents of Catholic Social Thought
6. Toward a Truly Catholic Church - Thomas Rausch, SJ
7. Catholicism in the Third Millennium - Thomas Rausch, SJ
8. Systematic Theology: A Roman Catholic Approach - Thomas Rausch, SJ
9. Models of the Church - Avery Dulles, SJ
10. Models of Revelation - Avery Dulles, SJ
11. Diversity & Communion - Yves Congar, OP
12. The Eucharist - Edward Schillebeeckx, OP
13. The Meaning of Tradition - Yves Congar, OP
14. The Experience of God - David Bentley Hart
15. The Selfhood of the Human Person - John F. Crosby
16. Nouvelle Theologie - Hans Boersma
17. How to Read the Jewish Bible - Marc Brettler
18. How to Read the Bible and Stay a Christian - John Dominic Crossan
19. The Interpretation of the Bible in the Church - J.L. Houlden
20. The Interpretation of Scripture - Joseph Fitzmyer, SJ
21. After Virtue - Alasdair MacIntyre
22. Amythia - Loyal Rue
23. The Rise of Christianity - Rodney Stark
24. A Secular Age - Charles Taylor
25. Between Naturalism & Religion - Jurgen Habermas
26. Theology & Social Theory - John Milbank
27. Essay on the Development of Christian Doctrine - John Henry Newman
28. A Church That Can and Cannot Change - John Noonan
29. Synodality - Rafael Luciani
30. The Works of Mercy - Mark Shea
31. Jesus: A Marginal Jew (Vol 1-5) - John Meier
32. God & Empire - John Dominic Crossan
33. The God of Jesus - Stephen J. Patterson
34. Jesus: A Revolutionary Biography - John Dominic Crossan
35. Beyond the Passion - Stephen J. Patterson
36. Paul Among the People - Sarah Ruden
37. The Resurrection of Jesus - JD Crossan & NT Wright
38. Sexual Personae - Camile Paglia
39. Just Love - Margaret Farley
40. Creative Fidelity - Francis Sullivan, SJ